Free homeowners insurance quote review

See what your homeowners quotes really cover.

Upload the insurance quotes you're comparing. We line them up side by side, translate the fine print into plain English, and flag the differences that matter most when you file a claim.

  • Coverages, limits and deductibles side by side
  • Gaps and fine print flagged in plain English
  • Questions to bring to your insurance agent

Free during beta. We don't sell insurance or share your info.

Compare your quotes

One quote per box. PDFs or phone photos; add every page of a quote to the same box.

Add details for a sharper report (optional)
What matters most to you? (pick any)

How it works

  1. 01

    Upload your quotes

    The quote or declarations page from each insurer you're considering. One quote works too.

  2. 02

    We read the fine print

    Every coverage, limit, deductible, endorsement and exclusion is pulled out and lined up.

  3. 03

    Get a plain-English report

    See the differences that matter, what to watch for, and the questions to ask your agent.

What we look for

The fine print that decides what you pay after a claim

Two quotes with the same price can pay out very differently. These are the details that most often surprise homeowners.

Replacement cost vs. actual cash value

Replacement cost pays to buy new. Actual cash value subtracts depreciation, so older items and materials pay out far less.

Percentage deductibles

Some deductibles are a percentage of your dwelling limit. 2% on a $400,000 home means the first $8,000 is yours.

Water backup and flood

Sewer or drain backup usually needs an add-on, and flood damage needs a separate policy entirely.

Liability limits

A cheaper quote may carry lower liability protection if someone is hurt on your property.

Extended replacement cost

Pays above your dwelling limit if rebuilding costs more than expected, often by 25% or more.

Ordinance or law coverage

Pays to bring a repaired home up to current building code. Without it, required upgrades come out of your pocket.

What you get back

A sample report

Example only. Insurers and numbers are made up to show the format.

The short version

Quote B costs $370 less per year, but it pays depreciated value on your belongings, has a 2% wind/hail deductible ($8,400), carries $200,000 less liability, and leaves out water backup.

CoverageQuote AQuote B
Annual premium$2,310$1,940
A · Dwelling$420,000$420,000
Belongings paid atReplacement costActual cash value
E · Personal liability$500,000$300,000
Wind/hail deductible$1,0002% ($8,400)
Water backup$10,000Not included

Highlighted cells are where a quote could leave you paying more after a claim. Every report also includes questions to ask your agent.

No quotes yet?

What to compare on every quote

  1. Same dwelling limit. A lower Coverage A makes a quote look cheaper without being the same coverage.
  2. Extended replacement cost. Is it included, and at what percentage?
  3. How belongings are paid. Replacement cost or actual cash value.
  4. How the roof is paid. Some policies pay roofs at actual cash value or on an age schedule.
  5. Every deductible. Look for a separate wind, hail, or hurricane deductible, and whether it's a percentage.
  6. Liability limit. Compare the amounts, and ask whether an umbrella policy makes sense.
  7. Water backup. Usually an add-on. Ask if it's included and at what limit.
  8. Ordinance or law. Pays to bring a damaged home up to current code.
  9. Limits on valuables. Jewelry and watches often have low limits unless scheduled.
  10. Flood and earthquake. Excluded from standard policies; ask about separate coverage.
  11. Discounts and fees. Make sure each premium includes the same discounts and fees.

Save it for later. We'll email you a copy, with a link to compare your quotes when they arrive. Sent once, no mailing list.

When do you expect quotes? (optional)

On your side of the table

We explain your quotes. We don't sell insurance.

  • No commissionsWe don't earn anything from insurers, so we have no reason to steer you.
  • No lead sellingYour contact details and documents are never passed to agents or insurers.
  • You decideWe show the differences and the questions to ask. The choice is yours, with a licensed agent.

Questions

Is this insurance advice?

No. Quotegrader explains and compares what your quotes say. It doesn't recommend a policy or tell you how much coverage to buy. Review the full policy with a licensed insurance agent or broker before you buy.

Do you sell insurance?

No. We don't sell insurance, earn commissions from insurers, or pass your information to agents.

Is it really free?

Yes, while we're in beta. You won't be asked for a card.

What should I upload?

The quote, proposal, or declarations page from each insurer: the pages that list coverages, limits, deductibles and the premium. Your current policy's declarations page works too, if you want to compare it against a new quote.

What happens to my documents?

Our AI reads them to build your report, and a copy comes to our team so we can follow up if anything goes wrong. We delete uploaded documents 90 days after your report is created, and we never share them. Details are in our privacy policy.

How accurate is the comparison?

The report is generated by AI and only reports what's written in your quotes. If something isn't on the page, it says "Not stated" instead of guessing. It can still misread details, so confirm terms against the full policy with your agent.

Should I black out personal details first?

You can. We don't need your name, street address or policy numbers, only the coverage details and premiums.